Skip to main content
About HEC About HEC Faculty & Research Faculty & Research Master’s programs Master’s programs MBA Programs MBA Programs PhD Program PhD Program Executive Education Executive Education Summer School Summer School HEC Online HEC Online About HEC Overview Overview Who
We Are Who
We Are
Egalité des chances Egalité des chances HEC Talents HEC Talents International International Campus
Life Campus
Sustainability Sustainability Diversity
& Inclusion Diversity
& Inclusion
Stories Stories The HEC
Foundation The HEC
Coronavirus Coronavirus
Faculty & Research Overview Overview Faculty Directory Faculty Directory Departments Departments Centers Centers Chairs Chairs Knowledge@HEC Knowledge@HEC Master’s programs Master in
Management Master in
Programs Master's
Double Degree
Programs Double Degree
Programs Summer
students Exchange
Life Student
Difference Our
MBA Programs MBA MBA Executive MBA Executive MBA TRIUM EMBA TRIUM EMBA PhD Program Overview Overview HEC Difference HEC Difference Program details Program details Research areas Research areas HEC Community HEC Community Placement Placement Job Market Job Market Admissions Admissions Financing Financing Executive Education Executive Masters Executive Masters Executive Certificates Executive Certificates Executive short programs Executive short programs Online Online Companies Companies Executive MBA Executive MBA Infinity Pass Infinity Pass Summer School Youth Programs Youth Programs Summer programs Summer programs HEC Online Overview Overview Degree Program Degree Program Executive certificates Executive certificates MOOCs MOOCs Summer Programs Summer Programs Youth programs Youth programs


About Inter-Stock Market Competition and Market Liquidity

Published on:

In the past decade, the upsurge of electronic trading venues, first in the United States and more recently in Europe, has radically changed financial transactions.

photo: the royal exchange building

Key Ideas

• Empirical evidence shows that trade-throughs are quite frequent and are prejudicial to market entrants.

• There is a negative cross-sectional relationship between the frequency of trade-throughs and market entrant competitiveness in terms of liquidity supply. 

While national stock exchanges had enjoyed virtual monopolies of their respective markets, increased competition raised numerous questions and generated revisions of market regulations. Hence the recent Regulation NMS1 in the United States and the MiFID2 in Europe. Transaction-related matters have been a major focus since 2006, but a crucial question has remained unanswered. What exactly are the benefits and costs of inter-stock market competition? Foucault and Menkveld’s study provides a preliminary response.

Insight from the Eurosets launch

In November 2007, the MiFID put an official end to national monopolies of European stock markets. The London Stock Exchange (LES) had anticipated this measure and therefore launched EuroSETS in 2004. This electronic trading venue was conceived to boost competition on the Dutch stock market and was almost identical to NSC, the Euronext electronic trading platform. EuroSETS consequently represented a fitting subject for empirical research on the impact of competition between stock trading structures (see insert “Research Method”), and its launch enabled Foucault and Menkveld to investigate whether “switching from a centralized limited order book to a more fragmented environment impairs or improves liquidity.” More specifically, the researchers undertook to answer the following questions:

• Does the centralization of order flow improve liquidity? Does competition between stock markets lead to an increase in liquidities on the markets?

• Should limited orders be protected from trade-throughs? Do traders have sufficient incentive to seek out the best prices?

Trade-Throughs as means to evaluate market liquidity

On a fragmented market, orders are frequently executed at prices that are worse than the best quoted prices. Indeed, traders often pay more for stock shares than the best market rate would require, because they tend to prefer one specific stock exchange to others. This practice is referred to as a violation of price priority or trade-through, and despite a lack of empirical proof, stockbrokers generally consider that trade-throughs discourage liquidity supply. Foucault and Menkveld have tested this intuitive belief using a model presenting two hypotheses:

• The launch of EuroSETS should deepen the consolidated limit order book (the sum of books across markets).

• There should be an inverse correlation between the liquidity of EuroSETS vs. NSC and the frequency of trade-throughs.

Competition and market liquidity

The researchers frequently observed trade-throughs that were detrimental to market entrant EuroSETS. They show that even when EuroSETS prices were better than those listed on Euronext’s NSC, only 27% of purchase orders for the stock shares in their sample were executed on EuroSETS. Foucault and Menkveld explain this phenomenon by the absence (at the time they conducted their study) of smart routing systems based on available liquidities in each order book. They subsequently focused on the relationship between the frequency of trade-throughs that penalize EuroSETS and its liquidity. They show that there is a negative cross-sectional relationship between the frequency of trade-throughs disfavoring the market entrant (in this case, EuroSETS) and the competitiveness of the trading venue in terms of liquidity supply. That is, the EuroSETS bid-ask spread relative to that of NSC is significantly smaller for stocks with a large proportion of smart routers and EuroSETS contributes more to consolidated depth for these stocks.  


1. Regulation NMS was announced in June 2005 by the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). It consists of a series of initiatives designed to modernize and strengthen the American stock market.

2. Published in April 2004, the MiFID (Market in Financial Instruments Directive) provides new regulations for markets in financial instruments.


Focus - Methodologie
Thierry Foucault and Albert Menkveld studied the entry of the London Stock Exchange on the Dutch stock market via its launch of EuroSETS. Before EuroSETS entered the picture, trading had been largely centralized in the NSC, a limit order market operated by Euronext. Foucault and Menkveld examined empirical data supplied by Euronext and EuroSETS to evaluate the impact of market fragmentation on liquidity. From May 2004 to January 2005, they kept track of 22 stocks traded on both NSC and EuroSETS. During this time, EuroSETS held approximately 3% of market share for this group of stocks.
Based on an interview with Thierry Foucault and on his article “Competition for Order Flow and Smart Order Routing Systems” (Journal of Finance , 2008) co-authored with Albert Menkveld, related to the research project Competition for Order Flow and Smart Order Routing Systems, funded by EIF in 2006.

Related content on Finance


How Inclusive Corporate Culture Matters in the #MeToo Era

By Crystal (yanting) Shi

European Central Bank at Frankfurt


Implicit Guarantees in the Onset of the Euro Area Countries’ Debt Crisis

By Eric Mengus

Social Innovation
Addressing the "S" Demands of ESG - Editorial
Eloic Peyrache - HEC
Eloïc Peyrache
Professor, Dean
Thinking Deglobalization
Guillaume Vuillemey - news vignette- HEC Paris
Guillaume Vuillemey
Associate Professor