Skip to main content
About HEC About HEC Faculty & Research Faculty & Research Master’s programs Master’s programs MBA Programs MBA Programs PhD Program PhD Program Executive Education Executive Education Summer School Summer School HEC Online HEC Online About HEC Overview Overview Who We Are Who We Are Egalité des chances Egalité des chances Career Center Career Center International International Campus Life Campus Life Stories Stories The HEC Foundation The HEC Foundation Faculty & Research Overview Overview Faculty Directory Faculty Directory Departments Departments Centers Centers Chairs Chairs Knowledge Knowledge Master’s programs Master in
Management Master in
Management
MSc International
Finance MSc International
Finance
Specialized
Masters Specialized
Masters
X-HEC
programs X-HEC
programs
Dual-Degree
programs Dual-Degree
programs
Visiting students Visiting students Certificates Certificates Student Life Student Life
MBA Programs MBA MBA EMBA EMBA TRIUM EMBA TRIUM EMBA PhD Program Overview Overview HEC Difference HEC Difference Program details Program details Research areas Research areas HEC Community HEC Community Placement Placement Job Market Job Market Admissions Admissions Financing Financing Executive Education Executive Masters Executive Masters Executive Certificates Executive Certificates Executive short programs Executive short programs Online Online Executive MBA Executive MBA Train your teams Train your teams Summer School Youth Leadership Initiative Youth Leadership Initiative Summer programs Summer programs Admissions Admissions FAQ FAQ HEC Online Overview Overview Degree Program Degree Program Executive certificates Executive certificates MOOCs MOOCs

Article

Envy at work: how organizations can improve productivity

Strategy

Envy between employees can affect a firm’s performance. In their study, Tomasz Obloj and Todd Zenger investigate what makes us compare ourselves to others at work and what this means for the firm we work for. They find that proximity to those we envy can reduce individual productivity.

Envy at work: how organizations can improve productivity - HEC Paris Professor Tomasz Obloj - ©AdobeStock-psdesign1

As humans, we continually compare ourselves to our peers and those in close proximity. But, how does this natural propensity for social comparison effect how people behave at work? Tomasz Obloj says, “There is emphasis on increasing transparency in the modern workplace. There are many good reasons to do so, reduced discrimination being an important one. However, this can also lead to envy between employees with detrimental effects on productivity.”

Selfish comparisons at work

Obloj and Zenger wanted to find out what increases social comparison in the workplace and how this would influence a firm’s performance. Transparency can reduce discrimination and lead to a more even playing field at work, but it can also foster social comparison between co-workers. “People tend to compare themselves to others who are in close proximity,” Obloj explains. “This may be geographical proximity (those in the same office), structural proximity, (those in the same organizational unit), or social proximity (friends or colleagues).” He adds: “When we look at someone and compare ourselves to them, we decide if they are better or worse off than us. Those that are worse off might induce compassion, and those better off tend to induce envy.”

 

Transparency can reduce discrimination and lead to a more even playing field at work, but it can also foster social comparison between co-workers.


Studying envy in social comparison 

Within an organization there are complex behavioral micro-mechanisms that can be difficult to untangle. An employee may envy another because their results are better, but what if the person who obtains better results simply works harder? “We were able to carry out an empirical investigation using data from a retail bank that had organized a tournament between its branches. Each branch was assigned to a tournament group where they competed for a different number of prizes: 1-4. If a branch happened to be allocated to a good tournament group, it had a higher probability of winning.” Group allocation was not based on skill or talent which meant that any element of envy or compassion observed in employees could be narrowed down to social comparison alone. 

Isolating and analyzing the data on envy

In analyzing the data, Obloj used an instrumental approach to find contexts that would unambiguously allow him to identify objects of envy. “The data provided by the bank created a perfect quasi-laboratory,” he reports. With the data provided by the bank, Obloj followed an ‘insider econometrics’ approach using a combination of all the big data from the organization relating to individual bank branches, coupled with detailed information from employee interviews, emails and company memos. “This enabled me to understand what was going on inside the organization and interpret the data,” he explains. “In the context of this bank, we see an upward social comparison where employees focus on those that are more advantaged. They only pay attention to objects of envy and show no signs of compassion,” Obloj reports. “We also see that when objects of envy are more proximate (structurally, socially, or physically), individuals become demotivated and reduce the amount of effort they make at work.” 

From a strategy perspective, Obloj concludes: “Organizations can use different levers to reduce the potentially harmful social comparison that we observe. They could make structural changes to their organization and alter the work culture to decrease the proximity of those likely to be affected by social comparison and become objects of envy.”

Applications

Image - Social Networks
“Firms can look at outsourcing as a method to remove the detrimental effects of social comparison in the workplace,” Obloj suggests. “The equity portfolio of Harvard University is a good example of where this has occurred. Here, the work had to be outsourced as a result of social comparison when employees and alumni were outraged at the high wages paid to equity managers.” When it comes to organizations and maximizing on economies of scale, Obloj believes these have limitations: “Parts of an organization may need to be outsourced if they generate high costs through high levels of social comparison.”

Methodology

methodology
Obloj and Zenger used data from a retail bank that charted an inter-bank branch tournament between 164 branches. As the bank branches were divided into tournament groups with different probabilities of success, the duo was able to isolate instances where social comparison occurred and whether this led to feelings of envy or compassion. They used detailed performance data in combination with supplementary material to create an overview of the inner workings of the firm. Regression analysis enabled them to determine that envy, driven by proximity to objects of envy, resulted in reduced productivity.
Based on an interview with Tomasz Obloj on his paper “Organization Design, Proximity, and Productivity Responses to Upward Social Comparison,” co-authored with Todd Zenger (Organization Science , September 2017).

Related content on Strategy

Dow Chemical plant in South Charleston, West Virginia. West Virginia Collection within the Carol M. Highsmith Archive—Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. (LC-DIG-highsm-31713)
Strategy

Walking the talk: why companies should be politically transparent

Pierre Dussauge MOOC vignette
Embracing digital in business education

How online learning changed my teaching methods

money globe ©Hyejin Kang-AdobeStock_vignette
Strategy

How companies can offset the risks of foreign investments

By Pierre Dussauge

CSR investment @doucefleur / Adobe Stock
Strategy

Sustainability indices: do investors actually care?

By Rodolphe Durand, Luc Paugam, Hervé Stolowy

Students in MBA lounge
Reinventing Business Education

Posing dilemmas: an MBA ethics course incites students to question themselves and their beliefs

By Afshin Mehrpouya

HEC Prof John Mawdsley talking
Strategy

Considering a diversification strategy? Follow insights from HEC Professor John Mawdsley

By John Mawdsley