Aller au contenu principal
A propos d'HEC A propos d'HEC Faculté et Recherche Faculté et Recherche Grande Ecole
& Masters Grande Ecole
& Masters
Programmes MBA Programmes MBA Programme PhD Programme PhD Executive Education Executive Education Summer School Summer School HEC Online HEC Online
A propos d'HEC En bref En bref Qui sommes-nous ? Qui sommes-nous ? Egalité des chances Egalité des chances Centre Carrières Centre Carrières International International Vie du campus Vie du campus Stories Stories Fondation HEC Fondation HEC Faculté et Recherche À propos À propos Corps professoral Corps professoral Départements Départements Centres Centres Chaires Chaires Knowledge Knowledge Grande Ecole
& Masters
Programme
Grande Ecole Programme
Grande Ecole
MSc International
Finance MSc International
Finance
MS et MSc MS et MSc Programmes
X-HEC Programmes
X-HEC
Doubles Diplômes
en Admission directe Doubles Diplômes
en Admission directe
Visiting students Visiting students Certificats Certificats Vie
Etudiante Vie
Etudiante
Programmes MBA MBA MBA EMBA EMBA TRIUM EMBA TRIUM EMBA Programme PhD Overview Overview HEC Difference HEC Difference Program details Program details Research areas Research areas HEC Community HEC Community Placement Placement Job Market Job Market Admissions Admissions Financing Financing Executive Education Executive Mastères Executive Mastères Certificats Executive Certificats Executive Programmes courts Executive Programmes courts Executive Online Online Executive MBA Executive MBA Formez vos équipes Formez vos équipes Summer School Youth Leadership Initiative Youth Leadership Initiative Summer programs Summer programs Admissions Admissions FAQ FAQ HEC Online En bref En bref Programme diplômant Programme diplômant Certificats Executive Certificats Executive MOOCs MOOCs

Article

The Impact of Overconfidence and Attitudes towards Ambiguity on Market Entry

Decision Sciences

For many people who have started their entrepreneurial adventure, the biggest challenge is to believe in yourself. Yet, for those who choose this path, confidence can also make the entrepreneur underestimate actual business risks, leading to fatal decisions. Researchers of HEC Paris Business School and Bocconi University offer a new explanation for why decision-makers often appear too confident, and shed light on the consequences of this characteristic.

overconfident young business man with a phone on a skateboard

Many of the key strategic decisions made in businesses may result in wasteful allocation of resources or excess market entry. For example, close to 75% of those who choose careers in entrepreneurship would have been better off as wage workers, and almost 80% of angel investors never recoup their money, both indicating that too many (unskilled) people enter into these activities. Similarly, an average corporate acquisition is more likely to destroy value than to add value.

Many of the key strategic decisions made in businesses may result in wasteful allocation of resources or excess market entry.

Why does this happen? One possible answer that we study may lay in systematic biases that decision makers exhibit when making business entry decisions. We focus on the behavioral drivers of market entry in strategic business contexts with two characteristics that are virtually omnipresent. First, these settings are inherently ambiguous. That is, we know what might happen, but we don’t know the chances that they might happen. Ambiguous situations can be contrasted with risky ones when we know the chances of what will happen, for example when playing roulette. Second, the ambiguity in such settings, and the associated payoff, is likely to be perceived by decision makers as related to their own skills, often in comparison to rivals.

old confident executive man
©Robert Kneschke on AdobeStock

These characteristics imply that at least two distinct behavioral mechanisms could explain entry into the ambiguous, skill-based markets on which we focus in this study: overconfidence -- believing that one’s chances of success are higher than what they really are -- and having a positive attitude toward ambiguity. 

Like many before us we use a laboratory setting to make more precise claims about causality. We rely on a novel experimental treatment where we change the level of confidence that individuals have about their own skills, and the level of ambiguity.

Decision makers are ambiguity seeking when the result of the competition depends on their own and others’ skills.

We find that decision makers are ambiguity seeking when the result of the competition depends on their own and others’ skills. That is, decision makers are more willing to gamble with their money on competitions where the distribution of outcomes is shrouded by a lack of knowledge about what will happen, rather than when they have precise data on the chances of success. When outcomes of competitions are more unknown, having the opportunity to believe that your own ability affects results appears to make them more attractive. 

Similarly, we also show that overconfidence only affects entry in skill-based competitions and does not appear in games that are chance based. 

Both overconfidence and ambiguity seeking can therefore explain why individuals enter into entrepreneurship taking huge risks with their savings, or why mergers and acquisitions often do not pay off.

 

Cover Photo Credits ©lassedesignen-AdobeStock

Article by Thomas Astebro, L’Oreal Professor of Entrepreneurship at the Economics and Decision Sciences Department at HEC Paris, based on the research paper, The Impact of Overconfidence and Ambiguity Attitude on Market Entry, co-authored by Cédric Gutierrez of Bocconi University and Tomasz Obloj of HEC Paris. Forthcoming in Organization Science.