Skip to main content
About HEC About HEC Faculty & Research Faculty & Research Master’s programs Master’s programs MBA Programs MBA Programs PhD Program PhD Program Executive Education Executive Education Summer School Summer School HEC Online HEC Online About HEC Overview Overview Who
We Are Who
We Are
Egalité des chances Egalité des chances HEC Talents HEC Talents International International Campus
Life Campus
Sustainability Sustainability Diversity
& Inclusion Diversity
& Inclusion
Stories Stories The HEC
Foundation The HEC
Coronavirus Coronavirus
Faculty & Research Overview Overview Faculty Directory Faculty Directory Departments Departments Centers Centers Chairs Chairs Knowledge Knowledge Master’s programs Master in
Management Master in
Master in
International Finance Master in
International Finance
& Masters MS
& Masters
Ecole Polytechnique
-HEC programs Ecole Polytechnique
-HEC programs
programs Dual-Degree
students Exchange
Certificates Certificates Student
Life Student
MBA Programs MBA MBA Executive MBA Executive MBA TRIUM EMBA TRIUM EMBA PhD Program Overview Overview HEC Difference HEC Difference Program details Program details Research areas Research areas HEC Community HEC Community Placement Placement Job Market Job Market Admissions Admissions Financing Financing Executive Education Executive Masters Executive Masters Executive Certificates Executive Certificates Executive short programs Executive short programs Online Online Companies Companies Executive MBA Executive MBA Infinity Pass Infinity Pass Summer School Youth Programs Youth Programs Summer programs Summer programs HEC Online Overview Overview Degree Program Degree Program Executive certificates Executive certificates MOOCs MOOCs Summer Programs Summer Programs


Using Innovations on Social Media for More Engagement? Be Aware of The Cultural Differences

Information Technology
Published on:

According to Instagram, more than 500 million Instagram accounts use Stories every day, with four million businesses using Stories ads every month. But Stories may not universally have the impact that influencers and social media platforms hope they will, of increasing engagement, and revenues, respectively. Two researchers share their learnings of their investigation into the impact of Stories on follower engagement with influencers.

stories_instagram - cover

Research shows that 98% of Facebook’s total revenue in 2019, amounting to $20 billion USD, was generated by the advertisements hosted on the platform. Yet social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram and TikTok rely on content creators to attract users, and this is what attracts companies to purchase advertising on these platforms.  

Among these content creators, a sizable number are influencers, whose posts lead to increased user engagement with both influencer and platform. In 2019, 39% of all Instagram profile owners who had more than 15,000 followers were influencers. Their posts comprise the main source of platform traffic, increasing the likelihood of higher advertising revenues. More engaged users lead to a higher number of people viewing ads. Influencers are attracted to stay on social media platforms and use them more if the tools available help them increase their follower numbers. Followers equate to currency for influencers. The more followers they have, the more valuable they are.


In 2019, 39% of all Instagram profile owners who had more than 15,000 followers were influencers.


To increase user traffic, social media platforms work to launch innovations to improve services and compete with other entities, such as the launch of “story” concept. Yet, technology does not create value on its own. Those creating value are influencers on social media platforms. Technology introduced needs to be helpful for them in reaching and engaging with their communities. We wanted to investigate whether innovations do always achieve this.

The introduction of the “Story” feature: a step towards “normalizing” influencers

The “traditional” social media post is a piece of content that influencers put time and energy into creating. They are staged items that are dressed up well and designed to stay on the platform forever. They might include a feature of a new fashion item, a performance-inducing sports drink or a clever gadget. In posts, influencers show themselves at their best and are aspirational, attracting followers. To a certain degree, the follower idolizes the influencer. Influencers are not seen as “ordinary persons.” The relationship is one-way, influencer to follower.

In 2016, Instagram introduced the “Story”, aiming to increase engagement between content creators and users. Instagram believed this would in turn make the platform more compelling for advertisers and raise revenues. The Story presents the influencer with the opportunity to post impromptu content that provides a glimpse of their day, for example, “I ate this pizza,” or “I saw this animal.” This type of post would remain on the platform only for 24 hours and then disappear. The underlying idea was to create more possibilities for influencers to engage with their followers. The Story is designed to be a filler between more carefully crafted posts.


Because the influencer is seen as more of a “normal person” through self-disclosure at different level, the relationship with the followers changes.


As a less-curated item, the Story is a tool that allows the content creator to produce an item quickly that gives a deeper insight into them, and which may be more revealing than the typical post. Investigating this, we saw that this leads to self-disclosure at a level that normalizes the influencer. Because the influencer is seen as more of a “normal person” through self-disclosure at different level, the relationship with the followers changes. While prior to the Story, the influencer might have been somewhat revered by followers, the Story may lead to more of a two-way relationship between influencer and follower. So we wanted to understand if culture had any impact on this. 

We decided to research what happened as a result of the introduction of the Story feature, and if this change was having the effect that social media platforms expected it to across the board, i.e. higher engagement. 

Self-disclosure is not always culturally appropriate

What we discovered was that in some cultures the use of the Story leads to a higher level of user engagement with followers, but in other cultures it has a detrimental impact. This is due to the “Power-Distance” element of culture. Power-Distance is concerned with the relationship between people in authority and those that are subordinate to them. For example, cultures that have a high level of power-distance include China, Japan, India, Malaysia and Russia. Those with low power-distance include Denmark, New Zealand, Austria and Ireland.

In cultures that have a high level of power-distance there is a greater level of respect for hierarchy, and there is an understanding that power is unequally distributed between different elements in society. This is considered legitimate and even desirable in such societies. Evidence from the research suggested that people in such cultures may not appreciate self-disclosure from those in powerful positions, such as influencers, though this was not well researched in the past.


There might be less comments on "Stories" in high power-distance cultures because people want to hold their idols up higher than them.


What we found was that people in low power-distance cultures were more likely to both like and comment on Stories and engage with the influencer. Conversely, in those where there was higher power-distance, while followers did like influencer Stories, they were less likely to comment on them. We believe this is the case because in high power-distance cultures, people want to hold their idols up higher than them and do not want to see them as “normal people” in the same way that other low power-distance cultures will enjoy and accept.

Social media platforms must consider all stakeholders and cultures

From undertaking our research, we highlighted that social media platforms need to carefully consider all stakeholders when rolling out new features. Not all stakeholders in all regions may benefit equally from certain features, due to cultural differences. This could impact adversely on advertising revenues, so is well worth taking into consideration at the outset when devising new strategies.

Critically, the Story is just one novel development from social media platforms. There are now, and there will continue to be, more new features in the future as these platforms evolve. Social media platforms need to take into account cultural differences in different regions when rolling out these features, noting that they may not be of equal value in some areas. They may even be detrimental to the aims of content creators in some regions. This could negatively impact on advertising revenues. Analysis in advance of development and running tests in different regions could identify unforeseen issues. 


Social media platforms need to carefully consider all stakeholders as well as cultural differences in different regions when rolling out these features.


Equally, influencers should not adopt technology for the sake of it. They should assess its usefulness for them and the impact on the specific communities they are seeking to engage with. This will help them to determine if the new feature will bring any value to user engagement. Influencers on all social media platforms should also consider the cultural implications of releasing different types of posts. For example, on TikTok, for some regions influencers should think about the content of their videos and the level of self-disclosure within before posting. 


Influencers should not adopt technology for the sake of it.




To assess the influence of the story feature on social media posts, between June 2016 and December 2018 we collected data from verified public profiles of 57 Instagram influencers, relating to 31,000 Instagram posts. Using statistical techniques, we sought to quantify the influence of introducing the story feature on the profile owners’ frequency of content creation and extent of followers’ engagement.


Not all new social media features will be equally beneficial for all across the globe. Platforms should consider the full range of stakeholders using their technology and the objectives of these different individuals and organizations when developing new features, since these may impact on the value that such entities can create. Influencers should blindly avoid adopting technology just because it is new and must assess what new features will do for them. They should also consider the level of “self-disclosure” in all posts, such as videos on TikTok and Stories on Instagram, thinking about how these will affect their followers, depending on culture. 
Based on an interview with Assistant Professor and HEC Paris PhD holder Reza Alibakhshi, and Professor Shirish C. Srivastava, based on their paper “Post-Story: Influence of Introducing Story Feature on Social Media Posts,” published in the Journal of Management Information Systems in June 2022.   

Related content on Information Technology

surgeon diagnosis with AI - vignette

Photo Credits: Have a nice day on Adobe Stock

Information Systems

To What Extent Do People Follow Algorithms’ Advice More Than Human Advice?

By Liu Cathy Yang, Xitong Li, Sangseok You

Photo Credit: NaMaKuKi on Adobe Stock

Data Science

How Do Algorithmic Recommendations Lead Consumers to Make Online Purchases?

By Xitong Li

pharma - vignette
Operations Management

Manufacturing Innovation Drives Pharma Sales

By Dimitrios Andritsos

mobile connectivity - mirko vitali - adobe
Information Systems

How Governments Can Take Actions Against Fake News Propensity

By Shirish Srivastava

man in suit meditating in the middle of contact technologies
Information Technology

Managing “Technostress” for Optimal Employee Innovation Performance

By Shirish Srivastava